MetLife fined $10 million over missing pensioners

Insurer's policies for locating annuity customers resulted in errors in accounting for reserves, SEC says.

MetLife Inc. agreed to pay a $10 million fine to settle Securities and Exchange Commission allegations that the insurer violated accounting rules in setting reserves for its annuities business.

For over 25 years, MetLife followed a policy of assuming customers had died or couldn’t be found if they didn’t respond to two mailings made 5½ years apart, the SEC said Wednesday in a statement.

The practice, in a unit that takes on pension obligations from employers that no longer want to handle them, boosted MetLife’s profits because it allowed the company to free up money that had been set aside to cover pension payments.

MetLife, which didn’t admit or deny the SEC’s allegations, later determined that its policy was insufficient to justify the release of reserves. To correct its error, MetLife increased reserves by $510 million in 2017, the SEC said.

“MetLife’s insufficient internal controls caused longstanding accounting errors,” said Marc Berger, head of the SEC’s New York office.

The SEC also found that MetLife overstated its reserves and understated income related to its variable annuity business. To correct that error, MetLife reduced reserves by $896 million at the end of 2017.

“Our focus since we self-identified these issues has been to improve our processes to deliver better service to our customers,” MetLife said in an emailed statement. “We successfully remediated both material weaknesses associated with this settlement as of December 2018.”

[More: Massachusetts finds MetLife ‘missing’ pensioners, Galvin says]

Recent Articles by Author

SEC Commissioner leaving next month

SEC Commissioner leaving next month

Robert Jackson Jr. to return to teaching at NYU Law School

Nir Kaissar: BlackRock muddies the social-investing waters

Nir Kaissar: BlackRock muddies the social-investing waters

The giant money manager is taking a misguided approach to climate change

Schwab’s zero-fee plan pushes assets to record $4 trillion

Schwab’s zero-fee plan pushes assets to record $4 trillion

Eliminating trading fees pushed client assets to a record as the firm faced a decline in trading revenue


Subscribe and Save 60%

Premium Access
Print + Digital

Learn more
Subscribe to Print


Get unlimited access to

Starting at $4.95 a week for 4 weeks


Pay just $4.95 for the first 4 weeks